# CAD2.0

## ![](/files/UnH9zg6PZHmkLaumFaXs)

## What is CAD2.0?

An open community of climate data experts committed to developing open, standard digital protocols that enable ambitious climate action. The community meets monthly and is co-convened by the [CAMDA](https://camda.global/) secretariat, [Open Earth Foundation](https://www.openearth.org/), and [Data Driven EnviroLab](http://datadrivenlab.org/).<br>

[See our declaration](https://wiki.climatedata.network/cad2.0-cop26-declaration)

[What is a Digitally Enabled Independent Global Stocktake? ](https://www.openearth.org/blog/a-digitally-enabled-independent-global-stocktake-digs)

[Sign up to join the CAD2.0 community](https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfJvkF3R2cRemu0HMWig5Coie0zlxA7qR1rRU8gRxD2-AznTw/viewform)

Contact us: <climatedata@openearth.org>&#x20;

[Read more](/master)&#x20;


# Overview

Future of Climate Action Data from Cities, Regions, Businesses, and Investors

**OBJECTIVES**

In COP25, Camda and its multi-stakeholder community set out a declaration for rigorously tracking progress and accountability of non-state actor climate pledges. While the aim is clear, the Climate Data 2.0 initiative will tackle HOW this progress and accountability can be  developed under an integrated and trusted system using cutting edge data methodologies.

**ACTIVITIES**

* Monthly virtual meetings
* Multi-stakeholder workshops
* Design sprints / scrums
* Parallel Satellite Workstreams

## Activities & Outputs

### **Climate Action Data 2.0 (CAD2.0) is an umbrella community that aims to collectively pursue the following:**

* Collaborate across key organizations and individuals working in existing data disclosure platforms and emerging platforms on blockchain, satellite imagery, AI, and other relevant new technologies in the climate action data and analysis space.
* Co-define strategic objectives and milestones with workstream participants that may include working toward supporting key products or moments within the UNFCCC process such as the Global Climate Action portal (NAZCA), Global Stocktake, COP, and/or efforts led by other organizations.&#x20;
* Contextualize outputs and strategies into a shared narrative and a common declaration of CAD2.0 objectives for 2021 and beyond.&#x20;
* Publicly launch the CAD2.0 collaboration at Climate Week NY and make a declaration from the consortium at COP26 on how to improve data capture and data quality over time.
* Produce a report or presentation to communicate initial findings and developments of CAD2.0 by December 2021 to inform a diverse set of stakeholders, including, but not limited to, the philanthropic community.

## **Introduction and overview**

{% embed url="<https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/14e0-BDWcVIWyEwBGDOsTS6ZHY_9sMHRZrv5DRf4XGzs/edit#slide=id.ge0b8f6817c_0_105>" %}

## Introduction Video to Nested Climate Accounting

{% embed url="<https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vkGHcfMV88I>" %}

## Our Membership Declaration

### Press release

> <https://racetozero.unfccc.int/tracking-credible-climate-action/>

### Declaration

> <https://wiki.climatedata.network/cad2.0-cop26-declaration>

**Template for sharing the declaration on social media:**

## Latest updates

Below is the outcome of our September 1st working group meeting to envision a Global Stocktake in real-time by 2030.

![](/files/-MjBXy0rHYvv4YiSgaAs)

## How to get involved

The CAD2.0 Working Group is convened by invitations to specific organizations and climate data scientists to ensure the sessions remain practical and relevant to the networks. However, if you feel you or your organization should participate in the monthly meetings, reach out to one of the convenors.&#x20;

{% hint style="info" %}
The Working Group meets over zoom at 8 am PST on the first Wednesday of every month.

You can register for our meetings [here](https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfJvkF3R2cRemu0HMWig5Coie0zlxA7qR1rRU8gRxD2-AznTw/viewform?usp=sf_link).&#x20;
{% endhint %}

{% content-ref url="/pages/-Mdz3XlLH7UB0Eso4Ld6" %}
[Meetings](/meetings/meetings)
{% endcontent-ref %}

### Contribute to this Wiki Page

Join as a wiki writer only if you are actively participating in the WG and meetings.&#x20;

[Use this link to join and contribute](https://app.gitbook.com/invite/camda-data-2-0?invite=-Mdz7nWw2wpW_BdLIYIz)>

## Working Group Convenors

### **CAMDA** | [camda.global](https://wiki.climatedata.network/www.camda.global)

We are a community of data and analytical experts, dedicated to providing credible climate action information from regions, cities, businesses, investors and civil society.

Our mission is to use this information to show how the world is transitioning to climate neutrality and resilience in line with the goals of the Paris Agreement.

### OPEN EARTH FOUNDATION | [openearth.org](https://wiki.climatedata.network/www.openearth.org)

The Open Earth Foundation is a research and deployment non-profit, using cutting edge digital technologies and multi stakeholder collaborations to advance open source platforms that help increase planetary resilience.\
\
We focus on open digital infrastructure by blending: a systems-based approach to Earth-level solutions, emerging technologies (e.g. DLT, AI, IoT) and a radical collaboration ethos.

### DATA-DRIVEN ENVIROLAB | [datadrivenlab.org](https://wiki.climatedata.network/www.datadrivenlab.org)

The Data-Driven EnviroLab (Data-Driven Lab) uses cutting edge data analytics to create solutions to the world’s environmental problems.&#x20;

The research group is an interdisciplinary collaboration of policy experts, data scientists, visual designers, and interactive programmers. The group is led by Dr Angel Hsu and is based at the University of North Carolina.\ <br>

**EXPECTED OUTPUTS**

* Whitepapers (policy and tech)
* Use-cases / case studies
* Tech & Data prototypes
* System mapping (stakeholder and architecture)
* Summary for policymakers
* Workshops Reports
* Recorded video discussions
* Video content (output summaries)
* COP26 Declaration & Showcase
* External Media Coms Releases

{% hint style="info" %}
The working group does its ideation sessions in this [Miro Board](https://miro.com/app/board/o9J_l495VDw=/)
{% endhint %}


# CAD2.0 - COP26 Declaration

This is the CAD2.0 community declaration that was launched at COP26

### Press release for the CAD2.0 COP26 Declaration

> <https://racetozero.unfccc.int/tracking-credible-climate-action/>

![](/files/xfvHexGWwMI5Igg83vIW)

![](/files/c5DZn95ke88mIho3HZYQ)

![](/files/3rQ4SRlagkj3Y48Qo33Q)

{% file src="/files/fjmhnaRhkLsGtO0Nbe6U" %}


# Member Directory

The following list will be populated with the participants of the CAD2 WG

If you are a participant, [contribute to this directory](https://app.gitbook.com/invite/camda-data-2-0?invite=-Mdz7nWw2wpW_BdLIYIz).  Add your email (mailto:) and your organization as a link&#x20;

| Member Name                                                    | Organization Name                                                           | Geography           |
| -------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------- |
| [Todd Edwards](mailto:%20tedwards@camda.global)                | [Camda](https://wiki.climatedata.network/www.camda.global)                  | Iowa, USA           |
| [Angel Hsu](mailto:angel.hsu@unc.edu)                          | [Data Driven Lab](https://wiki.climatedata.network/www.datadrivenlab.org)   | North Carolina, USA |
| [Martin Wainstein](mailto:martin@openearth.foundation)         | [Open Earth Foundation](https://wiki.climatedata.network/www.openearth.org) | California, USA     |
| [Isabella Söldner-Rembold](mailto:isabella@transitionzero.org) | [Transition Zero](https://www.transitionzero.org/)                          | London, UK          |
| [Marco Schletz](https://www.linkedin.com/in/marcoschletz/)     | [Data Driven Lab](https://wiki.climatedata.network/www.datadrivenlab.org)   | North Carolina, USA |
| Brendan Mapes                                                  | [Data Driven Lab](https://wiki.climatedata.network/www.datadrivenlab.org)   | North Carolina, USA |
| Melissa Hauser                                                 | Open Earth Foundation                                                       | California, USA     |


# Meetings

General details for meetings of the CAD 2.0 Working Group

{% hint style="info" %}
**The working group will have general meetings occurring on the first Wednesday of each month for 1.5 hours at 8am PST**
{% endhint %}

### 2021 General Meeting Schedule

| Date              | Topic                             |
| ----------------- | --------------------------------- |
| July 7, 2021      | Kickoff Meeting                   |
| August 4, 2021    | Workstream kickoffs               |
| September 1, 2021 | Future Data Visioning Exercise    |
| September 20-26   | NY Climate Week Webinar           |
| October 6, 2021   | Output designs (reports and maps) |
| November 3, 2021  | COP Preparation session           |
| November 1-12     | UNFCCC COP26 Events               |
| December 1, 2021  | Annual Wrap up                    |

### 2021 Workstream specific meetings

Workstream specific meeting will often meet on Wednesday 8am PST (same time window of general meetings) but 2 weeks after a general meeting.&#x20;

| Date               | Topic                        |
| ------------------ | ---------------------------- |
| August 18, 2021    | Dedicated workstream session |
| September 15, 2021 | Dedicated workstream session |


# 2021| July 6 - Kickoff 1

### Climate Action Data 2.0 Meeting #1 Agenda

(July 7 at 8am PDT / 11am EDT / 4pm BST)

&#x20;**Agenda**

·       **Introductions**

·       **Presentation: Climate Action Data 2.0**

·       **Guided discussion:**

o   What do you think about the working group streams/structure?

o   Should there be other groups/people that should be involved?

o   What other questions should we ask? &#x20;

o   Who would like to co-convene the ‘use-case’ group?

·       **Timeline/upcoming plans/milestones**

·       **Discussion on use-cases & policy relevance**

·       **Closing remarks**

## **Meeting notes**

\
**Evolving Themes of the first CAMDA call 7/7/2021**

·         Interest in organizing multiple CAMDA (COP) events

·         Relevance and focus of the global south

·         Mapping of the diverse data landscape - understand who has what kind of data and how we can harmonize

·         Engage with policymakers on the importance of quality climate action data

**Events planning**

·         Potential to merge **COP** side event with DDL - Interested merge parties to connect with Angel afterward

·         Discussion on **COP event** slot that is reserved for the CAMDA community depending on whether this is a closed or open event

·         Opportunity to participate via the UNFCCC dedicated to resilience frontiers for those members in the group that are more working on the adaptation side

·         Todd - if we are able to organize this group sufficiently before **COP**, we could also try to have an event at the high-level champions meeting

o   CAMDA is launching additional working groups on “Finance” and “Resilience and Adaptation”

**Workstream feedback**

·         “**Data** Robustness and Quality” - this fits across a couple of streams, as well as “what data is missing? Do we collect everything we need to?” Resilience data as well so we’re not missing half of the world

·         The need to be talking about multi-level governance here, but there is a political component here as well that we should all be aware of - how do we pressure countries to step up their game?

o   Importance of including the global south.

·         Linkage/contribution to the state of climate action report people (WRI) - to address: what are the most policy-relevant pieces each year?

UNEP Emission Gap - transformation tracking, data overview, close coordination between data providers and consumers

·         Consider a public call with the weight of all of the organizations here to create an open-source resource of all of the **datasets** out there and allowing organizations to create connections in and outside of this network. Make sure that we’re not talking just to ourselves and inviting others into our living rooms, but rather completely opening-up

·         Angel: we want to highlight some of the key problems within each area - we also have some ideas around what action items might be but these are not set in stone (Martin’s slide)

·         Reflection of how do we take into account what is happening with the **global south**?

o   It’s not that the data doesn’t exist, it’s that we don’t have access

o   What is the impact of failing MRV systems?

o   Angel: **Global south** issues and focus should be a thread across all of the workstreams

·         Would be great to have an overview on what kind of data is available from everyone in the group here, and what kinds of **data** will be coming into availability over the coming months/years/etc.

·         Perhaps we can record on gitbook **metadata** of all our resources, existing and planned?

·         Angel: Hopefully convene a data harmonization working group meeting at the end of July

·         You’re never comparing apples to apples - even if the **dataset** is available, there is a huge issue with making them compatible. Identifying which power plant is the same power plant across datasets is a huge issue for example.

·         We have all this amazing data but not a lot of people know about the **data** - so doing targeted outreach is actually very important as well

·         We want to bring **datasets** from the domain experts which can be used as benchmarks etc. to bring to the machine learning experts to utilize

·         We are in the foothills of this right now - it’s important to communicate to the **policy** world on how the work here, as well as accountability + transparency framings are necessary for the global work around Climate Change action.

o   In the past you might have private corporations saying that “we can’t do this, we don’t think that it is important to have full transparency” - now the move is that they’re hiding behind trade groups to avoid transparency concerns.

·         Significant gap in **data reporting** and data availability between **north and south** - we have noticed reporting fatigue

o   Getting people together outside of this community would be something that governments would also like and support I think

o   As we’re talking about net-zero and re-calibrating ambition, there is a massive desire to get the data to be up to date and assess progress now rather than waiting a longer period to assess progress

**First Data harmonization meeting** will be at the end of July/beginning of August

* First order of business will be a massive accounting exercise of metadata - what are we working on, what is available, what is the landscape
* Thinking about potential users and who might have needs and demands for some of the harmonized data we are working with

**Digital Infrastructure/Architecture** - first meeting is to be held before the end of the month.&#x20;

* Looking at the entire data trail - data collection, sensors, how data ends up being available or stored in databases
* Datasets are more than just data, they’re an embedded accounting strategy

Martin brings up a collective visioning exercise for the next meeting&#x20;

* Future visioning exercise (what would the future look like) - visual board of our ambition

Data trail (collection, sensors, raw data database flow, cleaned, trusted APIs, different technologies, signing data sets), minimizing compiling efforts, what are data sets

Feeding into accountability, costs and time resource, technical and political tensions, automated way

Todd:&#x20;

* This as an umbrella strategy across the workstreams is intended to include the strategic comms and outreach people, even though there is no specific group set up for it - but these people will likely live in the Policy/Use Cases group
* Anyone interested in leading the policy/use cases group should connect with Todd

| First Name | Last Name       | Organization                                 |
| ---------- | --------------- | -------------------------------------------- |
| Catherine  | Atkin           | Carbon Accountable                           |
| Roisin     | Gorman          | Climate Group                                |
| Michal     | Nachmany        | Climate Policy Radar CIC                     |
| Mark       | Powell          | Climate TRACE                                |
| Angel      | Hsu             | Data-Driven EnviroLab                        |
| Marco      | Schletz         | Data-Driven EnviroLab                        |
| Brendan    | Mapes           | Data-Driven EnviroLab                        |
| Cesar      | Carreño         | ICLEI - Local Governments for sustainability |
| Martin     | Wainstein       | Open Earth Foundation                        |
| Sarah      | Barrington      | Open Earth Foundation                        |
| Thomas     | Hale            | Oxford University                            |
| Jan        | Drgona          | Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, CCAI  |
| Isabella   | Soldner-Rembold | Transition Zero                              |
| Matt       | Gray            | Transition Zero                              |
| André      | Ferreira        | TransitionZero / Climate TRACE               |
| Ian        | Tout            | UNFCCC                                       |
| Massamba   | Thioye          | UNFCCC                                       |
| Mayra      | Santaella       | UNFCCC                                       |
| Lekha      | Sridhar         | WattTime / Climate TRACE                     |
| Leandro    | Vigna           | WRI                                          |
| Shannon    | McDaniel        |                                              |
| Henry      | Quintana        | Climate Group                                |
| Takeshi    | Kuramochi       | New Climate Institute                        |


# 2021| August 4 - Climate Data 2.0 Meeting #2

Second meeting for the CAD2 working group

## **Meeting time: August 4 at 8am PDT / 11am EDT / 4pm BST**

**7:45am/10:45am/3:45pm: Technical setup for zoom - breakout room tests**<br>

{% hint style="info" %}
Facilitated workstream sessions will happen on this[ **Miro Board**](https://miro.com/app/board/o9J_l495VDw=/)
{% endhint %}

### **8am/11am/4pm: Introductions & Catchup- Todd open and facilitate**

* **Recap from last session (Angel)**
* **Timeline review from Wiki (Martin)**

### **8:15am/11:15/4:15: Intro to Workstream topics and general expected outputs from the Working Group - Marco**

Marco introduces this section and facilitates some quick Q\&A

* **Angel: Data Harmonization**
* **Martin: Digital Infrastructure**
* **Todd: Use cases**

### **8:25am/11:25/4:25: Breakout Room - 3 Workstreams**

**Each workstream lead to organize a facilitator a scribe and a prompt for how to navigate the conversation and exercise. For each workstream, we will organize a ‘word cloud’ and a rapid ideation using this** [**Miro Board**](https://miro.com/app/board/o9J_l495VDw=/)

* **Data Homogenization**
* **Digital Infrastructure**
* **Use-Cases and Policy Relevance**                          &#x20;

### **9:05am/12:05/5:05: Sharing back from Breakout rooms and Discussion:**&#x20;

**Plenary facilitation from the representatives of each working group** <br>

### **9:25am/12:25/5:25: Next steps and NY Climate Week**

* **Closing remarks**

**9:30am/12:30/5:30: Session Ends**<br>

## **Meeting notes**

#### Angel - Camda history and rational recap&#x20;

* Community for credible climate action was founded \~4 years ago by group of people and organizations that are working in the non-state and sub-national actor space like universities and research organizations in partnership with champions of the UNFCCC
* Recognizing a need to be able to understand, measure, and track this groundswell of cities, regional governments, and corporate financial institutions involved in climate action that all of a sudden are a pillar of the Paris Agreement and key piece of the pledge review and ratchet mechanism&#x20;
* We're at a tipping point where it's no longer good enough to just use what data and information is out there -- the "garbage-in garbage-out" challenge -- not saying that all data out there is "garbage" but we recognize that there are challenges in terms of comparability and data availability&#x20;
* There are still a lot of actors out there that are participating in climate action but are not reporting on their progress, which makes it difficult to see how this adds up in an aggregate sense to get us closer to those climate goals&#x20;
* Over the past 15 years, there has been little innovation in the climate accounting space so this working group asks the questions of how are we getting to a transparent climate accounting? To use existing data and understand present gaps and also consider the massive digital transformation with the internet and all type of digital technologies (such as sensors, the internet of things, to blockchain, to other types of satellite observation) - how can we capture these lightning fast developments into the space of climate action data and accounting?&#x20;
* Understand where the needs and the demands of these types of technology applications are and how can we tailor the ideas we are generating to fit to very specific use cases?

#### Martin - Walkthrough of Wiki&#x20;

* See the purpose of the Camda working group, initial slide deck, link for you to contribute directly
* Provide feedback and stay uptodate on expected activities and outputs
* Member directory to keep track of CAD2 participants
* Meetings tab for general meeting schedule and individual tabs on meeting output information
* General "umbrella" meetings and workstream specific meetings&#x20;
  * Monthly umbrella meetings and workstream meetings in between so that there is a Camda meeting every two weeks
  * Workstream meetings (next Aug 18 and Sep 15)

#### Marco - Workstream overview&#x20;

* Growing the community to align efforts and not create another "silo"&#x20;
* Three different workstreams:&#x20;
  * 1\. Data harmonization&#x20;
  * 2\. Use case and policy implications&#x20;
  * 3\. Digital infrastructure&#x20;
* Refer to wiki for additional information. The wiki is a living "document", please feel free to add and review&#x20;
* Workstreams are interconnected which is reflected in the format of all calls. There is always time in the plenary to share workstream specific insights from the breakout sessions

### For today's workstream breakout session&#x20;

#### Angel - define what we mean by data harmonization?&#x20;

* Use word cloud exercise to identify common points of reference with respect to the idea of data harmonization&#x20;
  * Different data sets that measure some aspect of climate and policy performance - how does one piece of analysis compare to another piece? Are we measuring the same thing? Think about a framework to understand how the different pieces interrelate and how we can make sense of them&#x20;
  * Technical aspects - how can we do analysis on existing data sets? Need for common definitions and nomenclature&#x20;
  * Define key priorities and action items that we want to work on Martin - define what we mean by digital infrastructure&#x20;
* Gather different perspectives through the word cloud exercise and select key terms to move forward&#x20;
* Collective ideation of priorities and what we think are the action items coming out of this group&#x20;
* Focus on actual technology as tools that can be implemented in the climate action space, such as internet-connected sensors, distributed ledgers, artificial intelligence, big data - how these things can be combined&#x20;
* Similar to the internet which is our large scale infrastructure, based on open standards and protocols, as bottom-layer scaffolding&#x20;
* How all of this can help to optimize inventories and cater to the use cases workstream in a more effective and low-cost way by providing the data plumbing Todd - why are we trying to solve the data issue? What problem is it actually trying to solve in policy or in disclosure?&#x20;
* There are a ton of different use cases but knowing what these use cases also affect how data can be analyzed and vice versa&#x20;
* Looking at policy relevance and different use cases might be applicable to your use cases but also thinking outside the box about how it can be useful to solving real-world problems

### Summary from workstream breakout sessions&#x20;

#### Data harmonization&#x20;

* Breaking up data harmonization into three themes&#x20;
  * 1\. Comparability&#x20;
  * 2\. Standardization&#x20;
  * 3\. Machine readability & automation, processing&#x20;
* How to define these terms and what are the issues within them?&#x20;
  * Comparability at every level - different underlying assumptions, what is the truth here?&#x20;
  * How do we compare even within different disciplines - e.g. how do we define a "company" or "country" - what are the boundaries?&#x20;
  * Standardization for enhancing comparability. How do we make sure that we capture all the data related to a term (e.g. NY or New York)? How to do aggregation towards a single number? Machine readability - time-consuming to make data sets machine-readable that were not designed for it initially

![Exercise from Miro for the Data Harmonization group](/files/-Mgq76OfX70BU9PiXdQ0)

#### Digital infrastructure&#x20;

* Similar themes and overlaps with data harmonization&#x20;
  * Standardization of metadata and licensing standards&#x20;
  * Interoperability through APIs&#x20;
* Where to find and how to access the data?&#x20;
* Trust - how do actors know they can trust the data?&#x20;
* Key audience - the developer community but important that other actors such as policymakers also can use and access the data&#x20;
* Making sure the data infrastructure is easily accessible (API, open-source) and standardization&#x20;
* Outcomes & Opportunities: What do we need to build, what are we looking for? What do we need to build first, in terms of priorities?&#x20;
* Next step: Digest the exercise! What do we know and what do we not know?

![Exercise from Miro for the Digital Infrastructure group](/files/-Mgyiy3W35vAphKvJp3h)

#### Use cases & policy&#x20;

* How to use the core of technical expertise and then think about to what end?
* When we talk about use cases, we really talk about what are the climate challenges and how do we use data credibility and accountability to drive climate outcomes?&#x20;
* How can we make the data useful but also how can we partner with the other workstreams?
* What is the enabling environment to drive the data change?&#x20;
* Think about how we can hold sectors accountable?
* Need of data to shine a light on what actors are doing in the public and private sector?&#x20;
* Disclosure for the financial sector&#x20;
* The role of innovation and the private sector - an important part of the ecosystem&#x20;
* Use technologies on the policy synthesis side to take this work to the next level Opportunities in the UNFCCC global innovation hub to build Camda outputs in support

![Exercise from Miro for the Use Cases group](/files/-Mgyj8VXZyzm0NRdeRcM)


# 2021| Aug 18 - Workstream specific

Workstream specific meeting for the data harmonization and digital infrastructure streams

## **Meeting time: August 18 at 8am PDT / 11am EDT / 4pm BST**

{% hint style="info" %}
&#x20;Please register here:  <https://zoom.us/meeting/register/tJ0scemtqDIuGNZ2JYqv1j4AXKOOzhKG59te>&#x20;
{% endhint %}

This meeting is specific to the Data Harmonization and Digital Infrastructure workstreams, which spin-off from the general meetings occurring on the first Wednesday of each month.  The Working Group aims to bring together experts on climate datasets to develop new digital data harmonization frameworks and architectures.<br>

These workstream meetings allow for a deeper dive into key dialogue with the political, data scienc&#x65;**,** and communication strategy communities. The agenda for the upcoming meeting is as follows:

![Visual meeting agenda](/files/-MgyiBw6rhWNM4KhnpQQ)

### **Welcome, Introductions, and Updates**

* **Recap from the last session - Angel Hsu**
* **Wiki Review - Martin Wainstein**

### Recap of Workstream topics from the last session and general expected outputs from the Working Groups - Marco Schletz

* **Identify priorities and continue workstream exercise**
* **Identify next steps and action items for each group**

### Breakout rooms - 2 Workstreams

(self-selected breakout groups)

* **Data Harmonization**
* **Digital Infrastructure**          &#x20;

### Sharing back from Breakout rooms and discussion:&#x20;

* **Plenary report back from the representatives of each working group**
* **Identify threads between workstreams and goals**

### Next steps

* **Define priorities and Goals for the Future Visioning exercise**
* **NY Climate Week**
* **COP26**

### Closing remarks&#x20;

## Notes from the Meeting

**Welcome, Introductions, and Updates**

* Recap from the last session - Marco
* Wiki Review - Martin Wainstein

**Recap of Workstream topics from the last session and general expected outputs from the Working Groups - Marco Schletz**

* Recap
  * What do we mean by data harmonization?
    * comparability, standardization, machine, readable & automation, processing
  * What do we mean by digital infrastructure?
    * Open standards and protocol, interoperability, interconnections, open-source, scale, transparency, trust
  * How can we use digital data (use cases)?
    * Support, integration, transparency
  * See [miro board](https://miro.com/app/board/o9J_l495VDw=/)
* Identify priorities and continue workstream exercise
  * To continue working on digital infrastructure and digital harmonization to understand and better define use cases&#x20;
* Identify next steps and action items for each group

**Wiki Review-** [**Martin Wainstein**](mailto:martin@openearth.org)

* How to add yourself to a workstream
* How to add resources
* How to access meetings notes and information

**Breakout rooms - 2 Workstreams** (self-selected breakout groups)

* Data Harmonization
* Digital Infrastructure                     &#x20;

**Sharing back from Breakout rooms and discussion:**&#x20;

* Plenary report back from the representatives of each working group
  * Data harmonization:
    * Call for action, a summary of current issues and exciting resources, potential paths forward, adaptation, elements of equity, enable climate justice

![Exercise from Miro for the Data Harmonization group (August 18)](/files/-MhnlrvbZ_NCITFMqlvK)

* **Digital infrastructure:**&#x20;
  * Categorize key audiences, interconnecting the sticky notes to develop groups, prioritize opportunity gaps, mapping ongoing initiative for the UN, roles of existing infrastructure, limitations of infrastructure that is not updateable&#x20;
  * Red are new stickies building on previous workstreams

![Exercise from Miro for the Digital Infrastructure group (August 18)](/files/-MhnmDCrtZ8XzHJmBwGa)

![Summary of key outcomes for the Digital Infrastructure group (August 18) ](/files/-MhnmanpJ_djhL_2kDio)

**Next steps**

* Define priorities and Goals for Future Visioning exercise
* NY Climate Week
* COP26

**Closing remarks**<br>


# 2021| Sep 1 - Future Visioning

Third meeting for the CAD2 working group conducting a Future Visioning exercise

### Invitation

Dear colleague,\
Reminder: You are invited to join a recurring Camda working group, “Climate Action Data 2.0”, convened in partnership with OpenEarth Foundation and Data-Driven EnviroLab, to take place virtually on September 1 at 8am PDT / 11am EDT / 4pm BST and on the first Wednesday of each month.

Please register here: <https://zoom.us/meeting/register/tJ0sfuGgrD4oHND5RKw58anmcMi1h3UIZqji>&#x20;

If you have already registered for the recurring working group discussions, please check that you have the meeting information on your calendar. The registration information will be active throughout the end of the year.<br>

### FUTURE DATA VISIONING EXERCISE

For the upcoming September 1st session, we will engage in a participatory roadmapping/backcasting exercise designed to integrate insights and outcomes of previous working group sessions into an actionable roadmap towards effective global stocktake processes and successful implementation of the Paris Agreement. This exercise will be visually facilitated by [TofuCreatives](http://tofucreatives.com/).\
Please find below the agenda for our next Climate Action Data 2.0 call (1.5 hours in duration) tomorrow, **1 September at 11am ET / 4pm BST**.\
\
**Welcome, Introductions, and Updates (Todd Edwards- Camda) (10 mins)**

* Intros for newcomers
* Highlight: Maryam Navi and Desiree Llanos Dee&#x20;

**Recap (Marco Schletz- Open Earth Foundation) (5 mins)**&#x20;

* High level review results from two working groups and encourage using information in large group work&#x20;

  * Miro board activity
    * <https://miro.com/app/board/o9J_l495VDw=/>

  \
  DATA HARMONIZATION

  * Breaking up data harmonization into three themes
  * 1. Comparability
    2. Standardization
    3. Machine readability & automation, processing
  * How to define these terms and what are the issues within them?
  * Workstream specific priorities:
    * Build on existing resources and engage with broader community - importance of outreach and engagement activities (coordination with use case cases group)
    * Creating libraries of existing data sets - facilitating the merge of data sets

      * Development of open source tools, open repository
      * Taxonomies of climate data - without lock in

  DIGITAL INFRASTRUCTURE

  * Similar themes and overlaps with data harmonization
    * Standardization of metadata and licensing standards
    * Interoperability through APIs
  * Where to find and how to access the data?
  * Trust - how do actors know they can trust the data?
  * Build on existing infrastructure and find opportunity gaps

    * Review existing infrastructure
    * Create info maps, directories and repositories
    * Knowledge sharing with relevant actors

  USE CASES

  * How to use the core of technical expertise and to then think about to what end?
  * When we talk about use cases, we really talk about what are the climate challenges and how do we use data credibility and accountability to drive climate outcomes?
  * How can we make the data useful but also how can we a partner with the other workstreams
  * What is the enabling environment to drive the data change?

* The **future visioning exercise** is a logical continuation of this exercise to develop a long-term plan about where we **need to be in 2030** and the **intermediary milestones and components** we needed for this

**Global Stocktake Vision (Todd Edwards) (5 mins)**

* **Maryam Navi from UNFCCC GST to present on vision**
  * 5 year process takes stock of the implementation process of the Paris agreement, focusing on long-term goals and outcomes. Enhancing support and international support for climate action&#x20;
  * Components: information and preparation, technical assessment, consideration of outputs (leading to declarations and decisions)
  * Question Answers
    * How will data processing occur?
      * Secretariat: task force, roundtables, and mitigation will process data, read and analyze in pdf form → working on a platform to receive input in more than 1 format
    * What role will non-state actors play?&#x20;
      * Non-state actors will submit inputs and GST will help summarize or help them work together to collaborate, possibility to have a consultation with non-state actors

**Warm-up/Icebreaker: Rip Van Winkle (backcasting milestones) (Brendan Mapes- Data Driven Labs) (10 mins)**

* Intro to Tofu Creative
  * How long have they been doing this, what other orgs have they worked with, etc

    * Desiree; Chief Doodler&#x20;
    * Take advanced complex issues to simplify into creative visual work to get the message across

* **Explanation (2-3 mins)**
  * Rip Van Winkle is a story about a man who falls asleep for a long period of time and wakes to find everything different.&#x20;
  * Imagine you are on your way to climate meetings in NY and you are tired so you take a nap and wake up 10 years later and it is 2030. You see CAD a member you recognize and have many questions about current times. It's 2030 and we're making great progress on climate change! On path to net zero emissions! But how? What do you ask this person to find out how we got to where we are?
  * Add sticky notes to Miro board of what your questions would be

* Activity (7mins)
  * Do we have all the answers we need? Will we ever have all the answers?

![](/files/-MigqPiX0ycv5YBRCZdM)

**Main exercise: GST Backcasting (Brendan Mapes) (30 mins)**

* Create roadmaps for each workgroup topic
  * Blank canvas: add sticky notes, put words in chat, be creative
  * What are the key things and relevant findings that need to happen to get to milestones?
    * Using data harmonization, digital infrastructure, context/policy&#x20;
      * Milestones:
        * COP26
        * GST I in 2023
        * GST II in 2028
        * 2030 Future
        * What are roadblocks?

![](/files/-MigqTX89Lt6bOaZlv3h)

**Plenary (5 mins)**

* Discussion of activity
  * How do we achieve these great ideas for the future?
    * Can get stuck in roadblocks but need to focus on the how
    * Great use of grappling with policy and data in this form: what are the key conjunctures and forms we need to see, how to we get to pilot phase, scale, phase etc
    * Encouraged by Maryam’s speech and that CAD can contribute through this work
* Results: see Miro board

**Future Visioning Presentation** [**Desiree Llanos Dee**](mailto:desiree@tofucreatives.com) **(5 mins)**

* TofuCreatives visual scribing of session

![](/files/-MjBXy0rHYvv4YiSgaAs)

**Next steps: Todd Edwards (5 mins)**

* Do the work
* Political next step
  * Translate efforts into moving data 2.0 past COP 26
    * How to collaborate
* Objective for working group: detailed outcome for 2030 with steps and insights, problem sets, timeline, roadmap&#x20;


# 2021| Nov 6 - CAD2.0 COP26 Event

We recorded an introduction video on Nested Climate Accounting

{% embed url="<https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vkGHcfMV88I>" %}

Introduction video to the Climate Action Data 2.0 (CAD2.0) community and an explanation of our community-driven approach to improving climate action data quality with a focus on subnational and non-state actors.&#x20;


# 2021| Dec 1 - UN SG Accountability Task Force Consultation

**Welcome & Introductions: Marco Schletz (5 mins)**&#x20;

* COP26 & CAD 2.0 Review of miro board: Three work streams, visualization exercise, brainstorming activities
* Highlight this is the most important workgroup right now&#x20;
* The Camda year&#x20;
* Events

**Hernani Escoba the Secretary General Office: Martin Wainstein (10 mins)**&#x20;

* Summary: The need for greater clarity and credibility to create accountability, so created a group of experts that was created just before COP26&#x20;
* Consultations with stakeholders about:&#x20;
  * Scope of the group of experts: what will they look into?&#x20;
  * Final product of the group of experts: build on what is existing, what are gaps, provide recommendations, what is highest possible net zero commitment sin setting and reporting&#x20;
  * Accountability: when and how does this take place: COP? Outside of COP?&#x20;
  * Phase I:&#x20;
    * Suggestions for expert groups contributors and their skill sets (net zero is critical)&#x20;
    * Currently finalizing terms of reference: this group will launch in January and have a few months to finalize recommendations
    * SG Accountability testing overview&#x20;
  * How this community can help advance SG achievements&#x20;
    * Inputs are welcome even after TOR are finalized&#x20;
    * Any contributions are welcome from this group or individuals
    * How SG and UNFCCC can collaborate<br>
    * **Q\&A**&#x20;
  * Q: What will the TORs look like: what the accountability should be (ex. tracking)?&#x20;
    * A: No definitions, but are high level, don't want to be too restrictive, more focused on when and how this should happen&#x20;
    * Q: How to prioritize scope? Cities and regions, businesses, financial institutions A: Yes: there will be a tiered approach that can be applied globally. They will need to build on the work that is already been done&#x20;
    * Q: What would be the most helpful work our community can do to help? A: Send inputs as soon as possible&#x20;
    * Q: What are the alignments on recommendations? A: must look at gaps, do not know exactly what impacts would be, need to evaluate how to meet outcome expectations Q
    * : How will the experts be nominated and will it be a FT or PT role? A: they have been receiving names, but more focused on skill sets, small secretariat to support with PT, open and transparent process to nominate experts&#x20;
    * Q: Will this be a technical or political set-up and exercise? A: looking at skill set, looking towards more of a political high level set-up with plug and play data

**Secretary General (SG) Memo Development: Angel (25mins)**&#x20;

* Explanation: set the scene for SG Output Activity with brief explanation/summary&#x20;
  * Email requesting feedback&#x20;
  * Expert review group&#x20;
  * Experts using outputs to hold actors accountable&#x20;
  * Finance focus?&#x20;
* Plenary Miro Exercise: SG Outputs office/task force&#x20;
  * Collect bullet points for TORs for SGs&#x20;
  * How do we define credibility?&#x20;
  * What are our commitments?&#x20;
  * What should actually be tracked?

**Road to COP27 (Milestones & Next Steps): Martin/Katherine (30 mins)**&#x20;

* After our recap, we see how far the CAD 2.0 group has come. We have discussed what we want to achieve and how we want to achieve it (declaration), but where do we take it from here?&#x20;
  * This will not happen overnight, but we can focus on what we want to accomplish over the next 12 months. This will help structure the memo for the SG development.&#x20;
  * Plenary Miro Exercise: What do we want to achieve for COP27 and how will we do it?&#x20;
    * Section I: What are the product outcomes (technical outputs) we need from the workgroup sections? Keep it informal and have everyone add sticky notes as brainstorming activity (Katherine or Marco can organize sticky notes) 15 mins freestyle sticky notes 15 mins discussion Focus: What will each workstream do and who will do it? Data harmonization Digital infrastructure&#x20;
    * Section II: How will we use GST? What is our progress tracker model? How do we want to position ourselves?

**Announcements/ Closing remarks: Marco (10 mins)**&#x20;

* Encourage everyone to share on social media for declaration&#x20;
* If you have not seen this yet, here is the UNFCCC posting by “The Champions”, which does indicate that they have read, received, and acknowledged our declaration.&#x20;
  * <https://racetozero.unfccc.int/tracking-credible-climate-action/&#x20>;
* We are hiring! We are looking for a Community Manager!

## CAD2.0 Memo Draft

Link to the drafted CAD2.0 Memo - **How can the Climate Action Data 2.0 (CAD2.0) community support the SG Accountability Task Force?**

Provide your feedback and comments to the draft here: <https://docs.google.com/document/d/16Ve2aoIO4vflY6V-GjU1HPgj4vqAfdJdrDN8Qhg-Lko/edit>


# 2022| Jan 12 - Road to COP27

**Meeting time: January 12 at 8am PDT / 11am EDT / 4pm BST**

5 min - Welcome & Intros&#x20;

15 min - Recap of CAD2 Year/COP26&#x20;

5 min - Invite to Thursday Internal Meeting&#x20;

10 mins - RINGO Committee&#x20;

45 min - Plenary: Road to COP27 (Milestones & Next Steps)&#x20;

10 min - Announcements/Closing Remarks

**8am /11am / 4pm Welcome & Introductions: Martin Wainstein (5 mins)**&#x20;

* Welcome&#x20;
* Intros&#x20;
* CAD2.0: a broader community and can find more info on wiki

**Recap: Martin Wainstein (10 mins)**

COP26 & CAD 2.0

o  Review of miro board:

o  Three work streams, visualization exercise, brainstorming activities &#x20;

Highlight this is the most important workgroup right now

o   The CAD2.0 year

o   [Memo](https://docs.google.com/document/d/16Ve2aoIO4vflY6V-GjU1HPgj4vqAfdJdrDN8Qhg-Lko/edit)

o   [Declaration](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1CyrdXgHj3zGIEC8LZF_kopgRKXYt9TLqrPZD9-sD2Ro/edit)

o   [UN Hub](https://unfccc.int/topics/un-climate-change-global-innovation-hub)

Encourage everyone to share their articles, etc on the wiki in the Library under General resources

o   Links shared in meeting

·       ​​Jury Konga: <https://www.go-opendata.ca/>

·       ​​Marco Schletz: <https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fbloc.2021.789953/abstract>

·       ​​Sybrig Smit: <https://newclimate.org/2021/06/23/global-climate-action-from-cities-regions-and-businesses-2021/>

·       ​​Romain Poivet: <https://ec.europa.eu/info/consultations/finance-2021-european-single-access-point_en>

·       ​​Kyra Appleby: (diagram on page 5) <https://www.globalcovenantofmayors.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/21-1108-GCoM-Multilevel-Climate-Action-Playbook-1.pdf>

·       ​​Laurence Watson (Subak)

&#x20;       ​​<https://data.climatesubak.org/>

&#x20;       Feedback: <https://forms.gle/uTQppyiiUWA5Kg6b8>

**Invite to Thursday Jan. 20 internal meeting: Angel Hsu (5 min)**&#x20;

Invite others to help planning and encourage engagement&#x20;

o   Reach out to Melissa Hauser if you want to join&#x20;

Make it open for volunteers and then encourage specific groups (see below)&#x20;

o   Roisin (Climate Group)&#x20;

o   Climate Trace - Lekha and Mark&#x20;

o   New Climate Institute - Takeshi and Sybrig&#x20;

o   CPI (Matthew Solomon&#x20;

o   Tom Baumann&#x20;

o   CDP - Kyra. GCoM on regional/local contributions.&#x20;

o   Mark Roelfesma

**RINGO (Research and Independent NGOs Steering Committee): Angel Hsu (10 mins)**&#x20;

RINGOs has nominated 5 representatives, including DDL to participate in a consultative roundtable to the UNFCCC on the GST&#x20;

o   Call for Inputs by the Katowice Committee of Experts on the Impacts of the Implementation of Response Measures&#x20;

o   The COP, CMP and CMA by its decision 4/CP.25, 4/CMP.15 and 4/CMA.2, mandated the Katowice Committee of Experts on the Impacts of the Implementation of Response Measures (KCI) to receive input from experts, practitioners and relevant organizations in order to implement some activities in its workplan.&#x20;

o   The KCI invites inputs (from Parties and observers), in line with specified outline and timeline, regarding the following activities of the workplan:

1. Workplan Activity 9: “Identify and assess the impacts of the implementation of response measures taking into account intergenerational equity, gender considerations and the needs of local communities, indigenous peoples, youth and other people in vulnerable situations” as per annex I by 31 January 2022;
2. Workplan Activity 5: “Build awareness and understanding of Parties and other stakeholders to assess the economic impacts of potential new industries and businesses resulting from the implementation of response measures with a view to maximizing the positive and minimizing the negative impacts of the implementation of response measures” as per annex II by 31 March 2022;
3. Workplan Activity 11: “Facilitate, exchange and share experiences and best practices on the assessment of the environmental, social and economic co-benefits of climate change policies and actions informed by the best available science, including the use of existing tools and methodologies” as per annex III by 31 March 2022.&#x20;

We ask for any inputs on the from our community as to what points we should make at this opportunity&#x20;

Highlight how this could benefit CAD 2.0 and direct participants to Miro board with RINGO information encourage participants to add input, comments, suggestions

**Next Steps: Road to COP27 (Milestones & Next Steps): Martin/Katherine (45 mins)**&#x20;

o   After a great recap from Martin, we see how far the CAD 2.0 group has come. We have discussed what we want to achieve and how we want to achieve it (declaration), but where do we take it from here?&#x20;

o   This will not happen overnight, but we can focus on what we want to accomplish over the next 12 months.&#x20;

Plenary Miro Exercise (Martin): If we want to conduct this independent global stocktake at COP-27, what will it look like and how will we do it?&#x20;

Section I: Milestones - What are the product outcomes (technical outputs) we need from the workgroup sections?&#x20;

·       Keep it informal and have everyone add sticky notes as brainstorming activity (Katherine to facilitate)&#x20;

·       15 mins freestyle sticky notes&#x20;

·       15 mins discussion&#x20;

Milestones: What will each workstream do and who will do it?&#x20;

o   Data harmonization&#x20;

·       Data standards for reporting&#x20;

·       Harmonization- common taxonomy (company metadata)&#x20;

·       First year: aggregate data that already exists, harmonizing standards (is it feasible to think about a harmonized data dictionary before COP27?)\
·       Mapping structure: Data sets are out there but there isn't clarity or common metadata to map out everything that currently exists&#x20;

·       What are the systems and tools that are already out there? How can we connect different data sets? Focus on interoperability and clear and concrete GST&#x20;

o   Context (Policy) Develop use cases for GCAP data with select parties&#x20;

·       what are use cases with parties? How are subnational and non state actors useful?&#x20;

·       Clarity how NSA inputs can make impactful contribution&#x20;

·       We will learn by doing?&#x20;

·       What is the structure for useful information/reports/data created and shared?&#x20;

·       Collect data from local projects&#x20;

·       Data ownership, privacy, management&#x20;

o   Digital infrastructure&#x20;

·       Interface and design&#x20;

·       GST outcomes&#x20;

·       How would we see a GST that would be help: UI design process&#x20;

·       Independent GST ready to inform&#x20;

·       Global community driven portal for climate discovery&#x20;

·       Global portal- portal of portals&#x20;

·       Trust network&#x20;

Section II: How will these contribute to the GST?&#x20;

o   COP27 and move, What is our progress tracker model? How do we want to position ourselves? What would that look like?&#x20;

o   Opportunities for Contributions&#x20;

·       Technical developments - What? How? Who? (stakeholders) Leads?&#x20;

·       Standards and common practices - What? How? Who? (stakeholders) Leads?&#x20;

·       Info maps, directories, and repositories, knowledge sharing - What? How? Who? (stakeholders) Leads?

**Announcements/ Closing remarks: Angel (10 mins)**&#x20;

·       Encourage everyone to share on social media for declaration&#x20;

·       Reach out to Melissa Hauser if you want to join the Thursday planning meeting&#x20;

·       If you have not seen this yet, here is the UNFCCC posting by “The Champions”, which does indicate that they have read, received, and acknowledged our declaration. <https://racetozero.unfccc.int/tracking-credible-climate-action/&#x20>;

·       We are hiring! We are looking for a Community Manager!


# 2022| Feb 2 - RINGO GST Inputs

Meeting time: February 2 at 8am PDT / 11am EDT / 4pm BST

5 min - Welcome & Intros&#x20;

5 min - Speaker: Casey Cronin&#x20;

10 min - RINGO Recap&#x20;

25 mins - Presentations&#x20;

35 min - Plenary: Informal Independent Global Stocktake Activity&#x20;

10 min - Announcements/Closing Remarks

**Welcome & Introductions: Angel Hsu (10 mins)**&#x20;

o   Welcome&#x20;

o   Intros&#x20;

o   Encourage everyone to share their articles, etc on the wiki in the Library under General resources&#x20;

o   Invite to Thursday meeting for Informal Independent Global Stocktake for Feb. 22 submission

**Speaker: Casey Cronin to present: Angel Hsu Intro (5 mins)**&#x20;

o   Update on IGST and Climate works&#x20;

o   Gather more input from what comes from the iGST community.&#x20;

·       Timelines and benchmarks&#x20;

·       First submission is February 22&#x20;

·       We are structuring the iGST submission loosely around: Process recommendations Insights regarding guiding questions from the Non-paper Data and analytic contributions&#x20;

·       Is this focused on just national party actors or are non-party actors as well?&#x20;

·       We are thinking about "non-party actors" but mostly in national contexts. That is, submissions from NGOs, think tanks, civil society, etc. but not meaning subnational/corporate/international cooperative initiatives&#x20;

·       So I think this community has a very important role for submission about sub-national, corporate, international cooperative initiatives, etc.&#x20;

o   Helpful links for the GST:&#x20;

·       NON-PAPER BY THE CHAIRS OF THE SBSTA AND SBI (Updated - September): <https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/resource/REV\\_Non-paper\\_on\\_Preparing\\_for\\_GST1\\_forSBs\\_15Sept.pdf&#x20>;

·       GST Overview page: <https://unfccc.int/topics/global-stocktake> Others Submitting submission for IGST Andrew Clapper Ian Tout WRI

**RINGO Recap: Angel Hsu (10 mins)**&#x20;

o   RINGO (Research and Independent NGOs Steering Committee):&#x20;

·       RINGOs has nominated 5 representatives, including DDL to participate in a consultative roundtable to the UNFCCC on the GST&#x20;

·       Mention that the Article text is very generic right now and that RINGO needs to provide more specific inputs on the transparency (Art13) and the GST process itself (Art4)&#x20;

·       We can use the UN SG Memo for inputs&#x20;

·       To derive key messages to share during the RINGO call&#x20;

·       We ask for any inputs on the from our community as to what points we should make at this opportunity&#x20;

·       Highlight how this could benefit CAD 2.0 and direct participants to Miro board with RINGO information encourage participants to add input, comments, suggestions&#x20;

·       [Miro](https://miro.com/app/board/o9J_l495VDw=/)

**Presentations: Angel Hsu (25 mins)**&#x20;

CAD 2.0 community that could contribute to independent stocktake report (3-5 mins each)&#x20;

o   Mark Powell/Climate Trace&#x20;

·       Developing pilot projects focusing on meta data&#x20;

o   Takeshi Kuramochi/New Climate Institute Global aggregation of non state climate action&#x20;

·       Focus actors&#x20;

·       Three annual chapters&#x20;

·       2022 edition

![](https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/XhWnlkKxUy0zzEYFnYI3qID3xuiH0Qkujmh21tnaWBIZSYbfLIzNWt7klmRCZa5vE40BYikmyoIGmKy-vfSOov5t8b3IdEccbNFqgTCY5CN6c0DU0nkiuX5cjIE0ig-Wd9gNOwIp)

o   2022 edition: revisit most policy relevant ‘progress indicators

![](https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/amZ1zT5m5y_qx-m8_DMt_KzygDoblqNjDjM8KJ31Tbkb2NVNVdKVvf-BqQyKAPp375vjriwXiw83Pe0O51qoXUzryhhvef39FCvmxTOk5Xwlu-LPIxpCCFc6djM7Ibf0_LalTWe0)

o   Andrew Clapper/CDP

·       BAU CDP work

![](https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/ELv3ePkLMUs0zJn9Hc-7d_rKJ1pX7RqBOhFbqxukcUe-ZOPvpRkbtgPCnq3we2_-LJ8h7ujIuchwsHF6aXM_rTSBWOCJ0SIl_tZjT2DYqS5Zl0-ctZIo3Lj_4k0Q6IqVar5eFm8E)

o   Camda related work

![](https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/m-MADUTbX8jMvbV038h8NrHMqkSGNGm0BuXwVtBbi2YI_wTSpf3d0ZVIC5ETm0pH3HBmGQKm0o_nT0Z40H-hFUIRNrHKz44CDJoMXVBgW1X3hN5P8KwiabInR2Zel7Ie3zU8rQOo)

o   Challenges / Areas for development

![](https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/CB69hkUlAfHJ_A71ZVyUl7sOfn8hEUM-7hJDZZ-q5A3bLdy-2mn_q39T6eqRKAJwK750DfR9MCyWPCDKHsDZC_m7-m7M1YKKmb5g0SM-lkUNcBMbhe4thVNPY7cifPxRfATU0DuL)

**Angel Hsu/DDL - Machine Learning actors**

![](https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/OjGaLKP14x-qOagIVArQuR_J0dwsee3YyE64vw1MnvjKp_dFjDp7R4Q6QYWZxKazAABiCefvaSkyIK6Ixe3XlHjU40k4S7aaIEClSfBOgNL-IzhGCnUo2-oXr7qdzRAL61sNKWN7)

o   Harmonizing different actors and databases to make it coherent and pulling policy actors and validating data, then use models to look at state actors and non state actors data&#x20;

o   Impact of actors if they are able to meet their commitments: what is actually being delivered?

![](https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/gWzhnjEFTjP5UtogKUnSjqeXYRchQXoKL3ua8nnaycdNCHel_jQkw-KtHTKWgnzAh6xUiZ5SA-2ypOga4Ts-kq-MdFEcj2JwNGIZz-vPKV-0DRqWK4RX7uPK2QRbrI-i_EQnEFJc)

o   Web Scraping and Data Collection

![](https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/bEWwgIN5SR1z1jkJj6TOujvblyhxFOtOF936Wm8xpu9Oq_LlfBe7XpPPCIq1r6gatG35Tpd8EKfH1QuwlhFdpoQVLOVF9o2vMuhPAB-2b87Egj_aN7ulwIum45qLH_u8WAipGcuR)

**Martin: Start thinking about digital product for next workgroup session (frame and raise it as an issue)**

o   Open Climate Data&#x20;

·       Integrated framework&#x20;

·       Presentation of demo for prototype&#x20;

·       Earth layers: what is the data saying?&#x20;

·       State/non state actors: what data is being used/entered?&#x20;

·       Corporations: who is using the system and collecting data&#x20;

o   Data infrastructure&#x20;

o   Digital harmonization&#x20;

o   Frontiers Paper explaining OpenClimate accounting system <https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fbloc.2021.789953/full?\\&utm\\_source=Email\\_to\\_authors\\_\\&utm\\_medium=Email\\&utm\\_content=T1\\_11.5e1\\_author\\&utm\\_campaign=Email\\_publication\\&field=\\&journalName=Frontiers\\_in\\_Blockchain\\&id=789953>

**Plenary: Technical Dialogue to the Global Stocktake Activity: Angel Hsu (35 mins)**

o   Recap: RINGO comprehensive analysis on the miro to have background/context for the upcoming submission&#x20;

·       February 22nd submission for 2-3 page report/outline&#x20;

·       Outline: who are we and what are we doing?&#x20;

·       Problem statements&#x20;

·       Existing formation sources&#x20;

o   Exercise: Miro board to develop inputs for the Technical Dialogue for the February submission&#x20;

·       Mapping across various (non-state) actor levels to derive inputs&#x20;

·       Key organizations - who’s working on what?&#x20;

·       'Problem statements'&#x20;

·       ‘Key resources to consider (e.g. data & reports)&#x20;

·       'Key synthesis points' we want to emphasize.&#x20;

\=> Technical Dialogue Outputs Ask people to contribute to the google doc - people to provide inputs by COB Friday, Feb. 11.&#x20;

·       Information dump/contributions&#x20;

·       Submit by Feb. 22

Announcements/ Closing remarks: Angel Hsu (5 mins)&#x20;

o   Welcome Louisa! The new CAD2.0 Climate Data Community Manager&#x20;

o   Camda stakeholder call on Feb. 15th: check out the newsletter to get on the mailing list&#x20;

·       <https://miro.com/app/board/o9J\\_l495VDw=/&#x20>;

o   Encourage everyone to share on social media for declaration&#x20;

o   Reach out to Melissa Hauser if you want to join the Thursday planning meeting: no meeting this week

The final version of the Technical Dialogue inputs from the CAD2.0 community:

{% file src="/files/ZNiyL3VNCgXrhSXZBgNQ" %}


# Events

General details on CAD 2.0 Working Group events

## COP-26 Events

### CAD 2.0 events

<table data-header-hidden><thead><tr><th>Title</th><th width="150">Date</th><th width="150">Time</th><th>Information</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td><strong>Title</strong></td><td><strong>Date</strong></td><td><strong>Time</strong></td><td><strong>Information</strong></td></tr><tr><td>The Future of Climate Action Accounting</td><td>Nov 5</td><td>5-8pm BST</td><td><p><a href="https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScydC5UIhDpreeH4nF_G0EICQNv1IF_Fk8cMnrZ_UTJfGQ0BA/viewform">Registration link</a></p><p>51 Richmond Street, Glasgow UK</p></td></tr><tr><td>CAMDA Climate Action Data 2.0 - November Working Group Meeting</td><td>Nov 6</td><td>8:30 am - 11:00 am BST</td><td><p><a href="https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScpoxbCRQnp6dQmCEFXxd6ghmXFGFBWmMSedCbqUS0skJcaPg/viewform">Registration link</a></p><p>Climate Action Lab, Mandela Theatre, 51 Richmond Street, Glasgow, UK, Lecture Hall</p></td></tr><tr><td>CAMDA Meeting</td><td>Nov 6</td><td>3-6pm BST</td><td>Will be located in the Blue Zone/UNFCCC COP-26 Official Venue (the SEC)</td></tr></tbody></table>

### Partner events

<table data-header-hidden><thead><tr><th width="200">Title</th><th width="195">Date</th><th width="150">Time</th><th>Information</th><th></th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td><strong>Title</strong></td><td><strong>Hosting Org</strong></td><td><strong>Date</strong></td><td><strong>Local UK Time</strong></td><td><strong>Information</strong></td></tr><tr><td>UNFCCC Global Innovation Hub</td><td></td><td></td><td></td><td></td></tr><tr><td>Independent Global Stocktake (iGST) and the Global Stocktake (GST)</td><td></td><td></td><td></td><td></td></tr><tr><td>From Climate Research to Climate Services – How Satellite Observations contribute!</td><td>European Space Agency; European Commission - DG RTD; ECMWF; EUMETSAT</td><td>Nov 1</td><td>11:30-12:30pm</td><td><a href="https://www.cop26eusideevents.eu/programme">Registration Link</a></td></tr><tr><td>Digital solutions as an enabler for climate action</td><td>European Commission - DG CONNECT and DG CLIMA; UNFCCC; European Green Digital Coalition; GIZ- Make IT Alliance</td><td>Nov 1</td><td>4-5pm</td><td><a href="https://www.cop26eusideevents.eu/programme">Registration Link</a></td></tr><tr><td>From Earth Summit 1992 to COP26 – A Frank Dialogue on corporate sustainability and transparency</td><td>CDP</td><td>Nov 2</td><td>1-2pm</td><td><a href="https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfXYUBHNx7NqYdKqyzTKH2ARmgyQ4-FZlMMEo0bVSZ5OAXD8w/viewform">Registration Link</a></td></tr><tr><td>Government and Business Dialogue: Supporting Credible Climate Action</td><td>UN Global Compact Network UK &#x26; CDP</td><td>Nov 2</td><td>4-5pm</td><td><a href="https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/government-and-business-dialogue-supporting-credible-climate-action-tickets-198839282647">Registration Link</a></td></tr><tr><td>Accounting for Climate: Corporate Reporting Climate Change Information and the 2021 Reporting Cycle</td><td>Carbon Tracker</td><td>Nov 2</td><td>4-5pm</td><td><a href="https://carbontracker.org/cop26-accounting-for-climate-corporate-reporting-climate-change-information-and-the-2021-reporting-cycle/">Event Link</a></td></tr><tr><td>Under2 Coalition General Assembly</td><td>Under2 Coalition</td><td>Nov 7</td><td>10-3:30pm</td><td><a href="https://www.theclimategroup.org/under2-coalition-general-assembly">Event Link</a></td></tr><tr><td>Open Source Breakthrough for Climate-Aligned Finance &#x26; Investing</td><td>OS-Climate</td><td>Nov 8</td><td>1-5pm</td><td><a href="https://www.eventbrite.com/e/os-climate-cop26-2021-tickets-166524893439">Event Link</a></td></tr><tr><td>UNFCCC Side Event: Transform to Net Zero: Accelerating Non-Party Stakeholder Action for 1.5°C</td><td>CDP</td><td>Nov 8</td><td>3-4:15pm</td><td><a href="https://www.cdp.net/en/cop26/cop26-events">Event Link</a></td></tr><tr><td>AI for Climate Action</td><td>Climate Change AI</td><td>Nov 8</td><td>5:30-7pm</td><td><a href="https://www.climatechange.ai/events/cop26">Event Link</a></td></tr><tr><td>Informing the Global Stocktake: Emissions Reduction Targets and Beyond</td><td>CDP Europe gGmbH, IDDRI, Wuppertal Institute; CDP; Institut du Développement Durable et des Relations Internationales; the independent Global Stocktake initiative; Wuppertal Institute</td><td>Nov 10</td><td>11:30-12:30pm</td><td><a href="https://www.cdp.net/en/cop26/cop26-events">Event Link</a></td></tr><tr><td>A Clearer Picture: Towards Radical Transparency in Measurement, Reporting and Verification of Climate Action with AI</td><td>Climate Change AI</td><td>Nov 10</td><td>3-4pm</td><td><a href="https://www.climatechange.ai/events/cop26">Event Link</a></td></tr><tr><td>Building an inclusive Global Stocktake: How civil society can help assess climate progress</td><td>ClimateWorks Foundation, Reseau Action Climat, University of Maryland</td><td>Nov 11</td><td>4:45-6pm</td><td>UNFCCC side event, Skomer (Multimedia Studio 2)</td></tr><tr><td>Dialogue Meeting: Accounting for Climate</td><td><p>Carbon Tracker</p><p>Partners: CTI, FFNPT, GEM</p></td><td>Nov 12</td><td>11:00-1pm</td><td><a href="https://carbontracker.org/dialogue-meeting-accounting-for-climate-2/">Event Link</a></td></tr><tr><td></td><td></td><td></td><td></td><td></td></tr></tbody></table>


# Data Harmonization

{% hint style="info" %}
This workstream is hosted by the [Data-Driven Envirolab](https://wiki.climatedata.network/workstreams/www.datadrivenlab.org).\
Points of Contacts:  Angel Hsu - <angel.hsu@unc.edu>, Brendan Mapes - <brendan.mapes@unc.edu>, Marco Schletz - <mschletz@unc.edu>
{% endhint %}

![Exercise from Miro for the Data Harmonization group (August 18)](/files/-MhnlXVIvXZ-9E3JR0qd)


# Digital Infrastructure

{% hint style="info" %}
This workstream is lead by the [Open Earth Foundation](https://wiki.climatedata.network/workstreams/www.openearth.org)\
Contacts: Martin Wainstein - <martin@openearth.org>, Katherine Foster - <katherine@openearth.org>
{% endhint %}

![Exercise from Miro for the Digital Infrastructure group (August 18)](/files/-MhnmIktsUzTXJqcsVLS)

![Summary of key outcomes for the Digital Infrastructure group (August 18) ](/files/-MhnmanpJ_djhL_2kDio)


# Use Cases

{% hint style="info" %}
This workstream doesn't have a lead yet.&#x20;
{% endhint %}

![Exercise from Miro for the Use Cases group (August 4)](/files/-Mgyj8VXZyzm0NRdeRcM)


# General resources

This section is open for any working group member to add relevant files, links, methodologies, etc.

## Relevant Reports

{% hint style="info" %}
Nested Climate Accounting for Our Atmospheric Commons—Digital Technologies for Trusted Interoperability Across Fragmented Systems

<https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fbloc.2021.789953/full?&utm_source=Email_to_authors_&utm_medium=Email&utm_content=T1_11.5e1_author&utm_campaign=Email_publication&field=&journalName=Frontiers_in_Blockchain&id=789953>
{% endhint %}

{% hint style="info" %}
Infras 2021 - Infrastructure for Article 6 MRV and transfers – the potential of blockchain-based technologies

<https://www.infras.ch/media/filer_public/02/8d/028dd2ae-1ea4-464b-bb27-26d7e00d169c/3218a_report-sea_blockchain_infrastructure_master.pdf>
{% endhint %}

{% embed url="<https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg1/>" %}

## Climate Data Initiatives

(please add content here)

## Digital tech insights and topics

(please add content here)

## News & articles

{% file src="/files/-MiXxGB0UIzESSzspY54" %}
The power and promise of improved climate data infrastructure
{% endfile %}

* *please add content here*
* [EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism](https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/green-taxation-0/carbon-border-adjustment-mechanism_en)


